Our current iPad case is designed to work with both the new iPad with retina display (3rd and 4th generation) as well as the iPad 2.
Will the new iPad (3rd generations) fit in my old iPad 2 case?
Our old iPad 2 case is not guaranteed to work with the new iPad (3rd generation) which is slightly thicker. We always fit test our cases before we send them out and obviously we never tested new iPads with the iPad 2 cases.
Being made of natural materials, not all of our products are exactly the same. Some people have squeezed them in but it causes warping and potential failure of the material, not to mention you might not be able to get it out. Please do so at your own risk.